|
Post by dead sarcastic on Sept 16, 2018 3:32:00 GMT
Vote on the polls and give feedback. Click on the names to see the videos. P1Soulfrost
|
|
pwtr
New Member
Posts: 3
|
Post by pwtr on Sept 16, 2018 9:12:09 GMT
This two Best mv's in all match card. But unfortunately I have to choose one. In my opinion Soulfrost's MV one step ahead. My think is Soulfrost.
|
|
|
Post by fanofanerahighlights on Sept 16, 2018 9:32:11 GMT
I go with P1 here... This was so hard for me. P1's MV was a classic. Told the story of Okada very well. Soulfrost's editing was a classic. He edited it so well. P1 put on a just a little bit better job here. Because he tell the story amazing and he synchronized his MV with the song. Soulfrost just ended his MV a little bit quick. I can understand this was so hard and he worked a lot on this but in my opinion he should have add the Battleground 2016 too. But still great work from him. The editting part goes to Soulfrost but synchronizing video with the song and telling the story goes to P1. Thanks to this 2 editors for their awesome works!
|
|
|
Post by Arguden on Sept 16, 2018 10:45:17 GMT
My choice is Soulfrost. Both of these guys did amazing. P1's one was simply amazing, I liked the whole video but especially the first part was awesome. It was very well synced. On the other hand Soulfrost did very cool too, his song choices were amazing. And it was very smooth, that's why I liked it a lot. It was too hard to choose actually. Both of them were amazing!
|
|
|
Post by soulfrostx1 on Sept 16, 2018 16:16:54 GMT
This two Best mv's in all match card. But unfortunately I have to choose one. In my opinion Soulfrost's MV one step ahead. My think is Soulfrost. Thanks a lot man!
|
|
|
Post by soulfrostx1 on Sept 16, 2018 16:17:57 GMT
I go with P1 here... This was so hard for me. P1's MV was a classic. Told the story of Okada very well. Soulfrost's editing was a classic. He edited it so well. P1 put on a just a little bit better job here. Because he tell the story amazing and he synchronized his MV with the song. Soulfrost just ended his MV a little bit quick. I can understand this was so hard and he worked a lot on this but in my opinion he should have add the Battleground 2016 too. But still great work from him. The editting part goes to Soulfrost but synchronizing video with the song and telling the story goes to P1. Thanks to this 2 editors for their awesome works! I saved for part 2 But I understand what you are saying and I'll take that, and thanks again I appreciate the support!
|
|
|
Post by soulfrostx1 on Sept 16, 2018 16:18:27 GMT
My choice is Soulfrost. Both of these guys did amazing. P1's one was simply amazing, I liked the whole video but especially the first part was awesome. It was very well synced. On the other hand Soulfrost did very cool too, his song choices were amazing. And it was very smooth, that's why I liked it a lot. It was too hard to choose actually. Both of them were amazing! Thanks a lot my man!
|
|
pk
MEP GEN NEXT
Posts: 21
|
Post by pk on Sept 16, 2018 18:55:47 GMT
Soulfrost:I had mixed feelings about this MV,the idea was great but The execution for me lacked something. If You are doing a MV in chronological order and You have a story like the The Shield one. You Must have some quotes or some background recap or something like that because You are trying to tell a story. It had so much potential but instead The whole MV looked more of a Match recap than an actual MV. Editing wise I don't have any problem. P1: Nice MV Even though The MV base form is also a Match Recap You add some quotes and had a little background story showing emotions and putting those pics Was a Nice touch. Congrats for The edit. I've already voted in The polls
|
|
|
Post by soulfrostx1 on Sept 16, 2018 21:08:06 GMT
Soulfrost:I had mixed feelings about this MV,the idea was great but The execution for me lacked something. If You are doing a MV in chronological order and You have a story like the The Shield one. You Must have some quotes or some background recap or something like that because You are trying to tell a story. It had so much potential but instead The whole MV looked more of a Match recap than an actual MV. Editing wise I don't have any problem. P1: Nice MV Even though The MV base form is also a Match Recap You add some quotes and had a little background story showing emotions and putting those pics Was a Nice touch. Congrats for The edit. I've already voted in The polls Thanks man. I'll take notes for part 2
|
|
|
Post by dead sarcastic on Sept 18, 2018 3:27:24 GMT
P1: 7 minutes of pure awesomeness! This video felt a little long but your great structuring and well editing made it easy for the viewer to watch the whole thing. You definitely improved from your Ricochet video. I can see that you're not using some of the same editing techniques you use most of the time, which is good. I like how the songs you picked were very different from each other and also different from the songs you typically use. The first song was a perfect choice for the start just like the last song was perfect for the ending. It almost felt like an Anime with the voice overs.
Soulfrost: I'm very happy with the way you used "You Can Run". It was definitely the perfect song choice for the story you were going for. What I like about this, is that it's very different from all of your works. It's not easy to say that this is a Soulfrost video. It felt special, and the editing was pretty good. The story of their success always connecting with each other is pretty creative. Without one another, they wouldn't be as successful as they are now. The ending of this was epic. I do think it was better to end it the way you did, since by then every Shield member held the Workd title It would be a great way to start the second part with their triple threat match. Overall a very good video.
Vote: A Match of the Year contender for sure. You two will definitely have to face one another again in the future, as this is only the start to what maybe Fight Clubs first and EPIC feud. These two videos were fantastic but my vote is for P1.
|
|
p1
Junior Member
[TI8]
Posts: 80
|
Post by p1 on Sept 18, 2018 22:46:55 GMT
Thanks for the great feedback guys!
|
|
[pain]
Junior Member
Posts: 64
|
Post by [pain] on Sept 20, 2018 23:11:39 GMT
The two works seem similar since both are highlights of the combats of Okada and The Shield, but the difference is the edition I liked more the edition of P1 although only in the first minutes but anyway it was nice to see, in As for the video of SOULFROST they were only highlights of combats without any history behind
|
|
|
Post by soulfrostx1 on Sept 21, 2018 15:22:32 GMT
P1: 7 minutes of pure awesomeness! This video felt a little long but your great structuring and well editing made it easy for the viewer to watch the whole thing. You definitely improved from your Ricochet video. I can see that you're not using some of the same editing techniques you use most of the time, which is good. I like how the songs you picked were very different from each other and also different from the songs you typically use. The first song was a perfect choice for the start just like the last song was perfect for the ending. It almost felt like an Anime with the voice overs. Soulfrost: I'm very happy with the way you used "You Can Run". It was definitely the perfect song choice for the story you were going for. What I like about this, is that it's very different from all of your works. It's not easy to say that this is a Soulfrost video. It felt special, and the editing was pretty good. The story of their success always connecting with each other is pretty creative. Without one another, they wouldn't be as successful as they are now. The ending of this was epic. I do think it was better to end it the way you did, since by then every Shield member held the Workd title It would be a great way to start the second part with their triple threat match. Overall a very good video. Vote: A Match of the Year contender for sure. You two will definitely have to face one another again in the future, as this is only the start to what maybe Fight Clubs first and EPIC feud. These two videos were fantastic but my vote is for P1. Thanks a lot man. Means a lot, unlucky that it's the first time you pick my opponent ahah but that makes me want to do even better next time!
|
|
|
Post by CHARI on Sept 26, 2018 17:14:12 GMT
Soulfrost: For God's sake, I really liked your video without any doubt you are one of the best. I would have liked a bit more history in the video but that does not take away the incredible it is (I was also a fan of The Shield) I hope the second part of this fantastic work, good job bro. P1: I do not know where to start, you told Okada's reign very well and it must have been a hard job for all the fights he gave, the song choices I liked, the only thing that bothers me is that you always use the same CC you should change it in each video but it was still a great job. What a great match for God!
|
|
|
Post by soulfrostx1 on Sept 26, 2018 19:51:09 GMT
Soulfrost: For God's sake, I really liked your video without any doubt you are one of the best. I would have liked a bit more history in the video but that does not take away the incredible it is (I was also a fan of The Shield) I hope the second part of this fantastic work, good job bro. P1: I do not know where to start, you told Okada's reign very well and it must have been a hard job for all the fights he gave, the song choices I liked, the only thing that bothers me is that you always use the same CC you should change it in each video but it was still a great job. What a great match for God! Thanks a lot bro
|
|