|
|
Post by dead sarcastic on Sept 16, 2018 3:36:27 GMT
|
|
pwtr
New Member
Posts: 3
|
Post by pwtr on Sept 16, 2018 10:24:23 GMT
I will go with Fanofanera Highlights here. Tranquilo put on a good job here, appreciate that. But for me Fanofanera's video was better. Sasha Banks MV was not a good idea as Okada vs Naito MV but to be fair the editings are nearly equal. I give my vote to FH because of his idea and editing. Thanks to this 2 amazing editors for theri hardwork!
|
|
|
|
Post by soulfrostx1 on Sept 16, 2018 16:24:44 GMT
So: Fanofanera did a good job and well edited but the only problem is.. is that he put the matches but didn't show me why those matches happened and what was the sory behind them, I used to do this mistake in my rivalry videos too sometimes but I learned that putting only matches highilghts with no story behind is not enough... but editing wise and rest is good so overall very good job. Tranquilo Highlights... damn... definetely one of my favourite MVs ever, I love Sasha Banks and this music video was sooo good. The coloring was just awesome and your style is very different since I see you like to play clips speed a lot and you do it so right! Overall super good job! So yeah this one goes to Tranquilo Highlights for me! |
|
[pain]
Junior Member
Posts: 64
|
Post by [pain] on Sept 16, 2018 18:33:46 GMT
Obviously Tranquilo wins, I'm not a fan of Sasha Banks but I liked the choice of song, I thought I accompanied the story very well and the editing is beautiful. Fano..fanea? lol tries to do something better for the next if there is next
|
|
p1
Junior Member
[TI8]
Posts: 80
|
Post by p1 on Sept 18, 2018 22:37:33 GMT
Tranquilo: My God, that was an awesome MV. I don't have any complaints, song choice was great, editing was awesome and overall I think it may be your best work. Congrats!
Fanofanera: You also did a really good job editing wise, but as the others said, you should've put promos or something in between matches. I liked the video but it wasn't enough.
Vote: Tranquilo
|
|
|
|
Post by CHARI on Sept 22, 2018 22:25:11 GMT
Undoubtedly the two did a wonderful job, it shows a lot the effort they put into it. Tranquilo: The colors, the song, the clips and the voice of Sasha at the beginning undoubtedly fit perfectly. The duration of the video is comfortable for the viewer and you knew how to tell the story of Sasha Banks very well, very nice video as always.
Fanofanera: Great video but the Tranquilo video is perfect sorry bro.
|
|
pk
MEP GEN NEXT
Posts: 21
|
Post by pk on Sept 27, 2018 22:19:42 GMT
Can't believe that I forgot to vote for this match since it was my favorite one from the comp. Tranquilo: It was a really cool looking mv, Since I've never cared about women's wrestling that much and I don't really like Sasha I can't say a lot about your storytelling, but the parts that I understood were great, the editing was also cool even though I just wish that the slow-mo was smoother I enjoyed the mv, but for the slow-mo stuff I recommend you to use the speed ramping technique It's really helpful and I can guarantee you it will make your videos better, the colorings reminded me a lot the videos about couples and that stuff...Really cool looking MV.
Fan of An Era: The video was great, the current NJPW for me is a Pain in the ass but you actually made it look good, editing wise you clearly know what you want to do and normally don't experiment a lot with that, but I strongly recommend you to do it. That creativity with the effects and storytelling will make your videos great.
Overall both are great editors and in my opinion, your match was the toughest one to rate.
Voted in the Polls.
|
|
|
|
Post by Arguden on Sept 28, 2018 20:42:10 GMT
Tranquilo: Very great work, although I usually don't like lots of slow motions, this was really amazing. It fits Sasha Banks so well!
Fanofanera: Probably one of your best, I know that you worked really hard for the video. Your flickers and shakes were pretty cool.
The winner is declared I guess, so congrats Tranquilo! I already voted.
|
|
|
|
Post by dead sarcastic on Sept 29, 2018 14:33:25 GMT
Tranquilo: Like I said, this is by far your best work. Mainly because of some of the things in your editing repertoire that you polished. Especially your CC on this, it looked very beautiful. There is one thing that kind of bothered me though and that's the speed up of clips. You shouldn't do it on almost every clip. Only use it at a small number of times throughoutyour gideos. They looked smooth but at times it can be annoying to look at. Regardless, this was my favorite video of the competition and you did a fantastic job!
Fanofanera: Just like Tranquilo, this is probably your best work. Your editing is getting better and the concept was pretty good as well. However, I do think this could have been structured better since I feel like this could have been shorter and I do think that haveing the song repeated again was a bad choice. I feel like you should have included more of their story in this, such as Naito winning both G1 Finals. Also, their last match should have gotten their own song instead of the same One Ok Rock song. This was still awesome and I'm proud of you!
Vote: Tranquilo. The final is going to be one hell of a match.
|
|
![[pain] Avatar](http://storage.proboards.com/6978781/avatar/OyZyWEHDcNvmFHecFcDk.jpg)
