|
Post by dead sarcastic on Dec 23, 2018 2:36:12 GMT
Make sure to give a reasonable amount of feedback (minimum of 5 lines) and to vote in the polls.
Fanofanera:
sarcastic:
|
|
undisputed
New Member
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCYKH6rNgUMZrqfYReLl4mXg/featured?view_as=subscriber
Posts: 20
|
Post by undisputed on Dec 24, 2018 0:32:01 GMT
Fanofanera: What an amazing edit bro, CC was amazing, the sync was top notch. This was a lovely edit and an amazing improvement.
Sarcastic: I am just speechless, this is even an improvement for you and that's hard to do. I loved the concept of the love of pro wrestling and the evolution of it across the indie scene and the wwe losing from it. What an amazing job and it actually made me shed tears.
Both did an amazing job by my vote goes to Sarcastic!
|
|
pk
MEP GEN NEXT
Posts: 21
|
Post by pk on Dec 25, 2018 20:11:15 GMT
FanOfAnEra: The editing was great, I think is cool when people actually make a Tribute to their favorite superstars. What I loved: You really know Hunter history and there´s nothing missing is an actual mv of HHH's full-time career. What I Enjoyed: Some of the LUT'S were great and aesthetic although I think for an MV like this one...A CROP effect was needed for more of an epic feel.
The music selection, in my opinion, wasn`t the right one. Sometimes you nailed but the Manson part and the Kaleo part, in my opinion, was not the right choice (mostly the Manson bit). That was the time he was a face in 08/09 and he was slowly turning into a company man, so I don´t think it was the best choice. Some clip selection here and there but with more experience, you'll learn that kind of stuff. Also, the MV gave me some strong vibes from SEM, GeFreak and those editors even the title was written like they used to do it. But also with experience, you soon will be finding your own style. Overall it was a great video.
Sarcastic: You really put everything on the line in this MV. You definitely feel like an MVZone editor, you took all the feedback they mostly post and put your own trademark in the videos. Amazing Stuff man. I can`t really complain about a lot of things, but you are the living and walking prove about what I said to FOAE, you found your own style after some experiments and some vids, now you know what kind of clips you need to put to make the MV better. In this site, we are probably the older editors. So yeah that´s something.
There are still some people missing from voting but to whoever I'm facing is going to be great.
|
|
p1
Junior Member
[TI8]
Posts: 80
|
Post by p1 on Jan 9, 2019 9:10:45 GMT
Fanofanera: You did an absolutely great job here, told Hunter's story very well and edited it really, really good. I liked the songs, too. Kudos!
Sarcastic: I really don't know where to start with this one. Everything was near-perfectly done and it was (especially the third part) very emotional. Fantastic work man!
Great job to both but my vote goes to Sarcastic.
|
|
|
Post by Arguden on Jan 10, 2019 16:02:31 GMT
Fanofanera: Really great work right there, really loved your CC's and transitions. Also old clips were looking pretty great actually, the only problem about your MV was your song choices in my opinion. I didn't like some of them to be honest but this doesn't mean that the others were bad. To sum up, great work as usual!
Sarcastic: Very impressive! Your storytelling, effects, transitions, were perfect. Especially your song choices were on point! All of them were perfect. You introduced me to new bands and songs, so thanks for it! There is nothing to complain about, this was just awesome.
My vote goes to Sarcastic.
|
|
|
Post by soulfrostx1 on Jan 11, 2019 17:09:30 GMT
Fanofanera, I loved this, very good stuff,captured HHH's best moments, very good editing and very emotional, especially with the undertaker part. Very good job overall.
Sarcastic, I loved this too, I mean you just really can't say much, there was a lot of good stuff but all I can say is editing was sharp he heck, very good, there were some very creative transitions and effects in this so I liked it a lot, very creative, that's probably what makes you different from everyone else in the highlight community. CREATIVITY. Fantastic job.
I loved both, this was very hard, I'm going for sarcastic but.. I think that Fan definetely deserves a title shot after PK and Sarcastic match-up, this was a masterpiece. Great job guys.
|
|
riot
New Member
Posts: 10
|
Post by riot on Jan 11, 2019 20:03:11 GMT
Fanofanera : Amazing MV, i really liked the way it was edited, and the songs used, really showcased his career well...well from what i know, sync was great and it was probabaly your best video.
Sarcastic : Honestly the best MV ive ever seen, extra points for having Ospreay in it! Great songs which got stuck in my head, great sync, you get better with every video.
Both did extremely great telling the stories of Triples H's career, and of the independent wrestling scene.
My vote goes to Sarcastic!
|
|
headcheese
MEP GEN NEXT
The Cheesiest Head
Posts: 19
|
Post by headcheese on Jan 12, 2019 4:39:05 GMT
Fanofanera - I liked the variety of effects and you had every section used have different effects like a one person mep. I think it was a cool idea of doing a black fade for your sections. It might be personal thing but, I would have liked to more promos and character stuff (Specifically in the Shawn Micheals reuniting and his face turn). I like the transitions and speed ups. I also liked how you ended with your name.
Sarcastic - This is mostly things I noticed in rerewatch and over analysis. I liked the combination of the Cody promo with the Nobody owns wrestling and having person talk about something else he is enjoying I assume to Shar the diversity. I liked the that you should Neville holding a red Raw ropes to PAC being the of Red (the Dragon Gate stable). And I really liked the focus on hand gesters 5:11-5:30.
Voting Sarcastic
|
|