|
Post by stylopz on Aug 14, 2021 22:52:15 GMT
Remember to vote and feedback both videos (make sure to give substantial feedback). Failure to do so will cause one point to be deducted. Due date is 29th August.
Golden Broskis (c):
Noel Gallagher's Fan Club
|
|
|
Post by Storm on Aug 20, 2021 13:02:39 GMT
Noel Gallagher's Fan Club: First of all, I loved your selections of songs! So creative and unique! I said recently in A2E that most of Roman Reigns MVs I have seen recently were repetitive and not really interesting, this one is one of the rare ones that's pretty good! Your use of review about Roman was something really unique, I don't know who that guy was but I guess that was you guys trying to show it as a view of IWC. Mask Off is a classic and honestly really fitting choice for Roman. Really loved how you made this part feel very dreamy like and used memes as a subtle reminder how no matter what he accomplished people didn't like him. Use of him talking about some deeper character was a fantastic way to use it as a bridge towards him changing his attitude. This section becomes way more violent and serious which is a perfect contrast towards the first section, especially with more intense song choice. Editing in both sections was super good and honestly you guys compliment each other so well it's impossible to tell who edited which part. Ending was so well done with song building up and Roman hyping up himself just for it to end with a calm and important message. Honestly when I saw nearly 7 minutes Roman Reigns MV I wasn't happy to watch that but damn you guys nailed it! Thank you for giving us a challenge to defend tag team titles against you guys and thank you for making such an amazing edit for our match!
|
|
Sami
New Member
[TI11]
Posts: 34
|
Post by Sami on Aug 28, 2021 15:59:18 GMT
Golden Broskis : Amazing video, I loved the duration of the clips it was perfect and almost each of them fit perfectly with the song for example 0:27-0:29/0:30-0:32 but there are a lot for me to quote all of them). The effects used correspond perfectly with Bray and I loved the different shots on the Wyatt family. There even was a scary ambiance and you tried to add awkward clips (2:00-2:18) and it was a great idea. All the shots onto his face, smile and how you showed his violent side during chorus was amazing and you did it greatly.
Noel Gallagher's Fan Club : Very good video and I loved the idea of what you tried to do and you dit it very well. However there are a few things on which I'd like to say something : I didn't find a big difference between the two sides you tried to show us. I mean it was difficult to see a difference between his face side and heel side, I think you could have showed his face side at first, show the Payback moment with a different effect and filter and the going for his heel side with another filter, allowing to see 2 clear different parts. And second thing is the pictures poping out during the "first part" of the video that were a bit too much and that wasn't necessary in my opinion. It was still a great video with how I said earlier a good idea, I enjoyed it !
|
|
p1
Junior Member
[TI8]
Posts: 80
|
Post by p1 on Aug 29, 2021 12:48:32 GMT
Golden Bromates: You two work so well together, every video you did so far was great and this one is no different. Song choice was great, it could've worked with any Bray Wyatt character, but I'm glad that it was this one, simply because it's more enjoyable to work with than The Fiend in my opinion. It was more than 3 minutes long and fast paced nearly all the time, but it never felt overdone. That was all due to clip selection that was similar enough so it showcases different parts of his persona and the violence he brings well, yet diverse enough for it to not seem stale at any point. Can't say much else to be honest, I can praise the video forever and it probably still wouldn't be enough. Fantastic piece of business.
Noel Gallagher's Fan Club: Ah, yes. I was waiting for somebody to do a Roman MV like this, showcasing both of his characters. Intro was super well done and it's great as an idea, it sets the point straight and explains the topic of the video. Roman didn't change because he wasn't successful; he changed because he wanted to be accepted. Song choices were really unique and fit the topic well, the story was told well and the point was sent across with good usage of voiceovers. The only criticism I have is: you should've differentiated the CCs between the two characters, I feel even a small change would've done the job. Anyway, this was an outstanding work by both of you, I loved it.
Again, can anybody miss in this comp?
|
|
|
Post by Arguden on Aug 29, 2021 15:52:10 GMT
Golden Broskis: This is one of the best videos of the year and definitely the best one I've seen in a while. I fuck with the CC so hard, syncing and clip choices are also so fucking good. You guys absolutely killed it, I even think that this is both of your best work including all of your solo videos too. And no, I'm not saying these because of the song, you can trust me in this one.
Noel Gallagher Fan Club: Honestly this video was even better than what I was expecting. The first thing that really caught my attention and got me interested was Mask Off, it's such a legendary song and it worked pretty well with the first part. Editing overall was pretty good, not the biggest fan of the B&W CC but it is what it is. Overall this was a pretty dope video, awesome work guys.
|
|
Absolutely not WWE Editor
Guest
|
Post by Absolutely not WWE Editor on Aug 29, 2021 16:00:53 GMT
Golden Broskis: This is one of the best videos of the year and definitely the best one I've seen in a while. I fuck with the CC so hard, syncing and clip choices are also so fucking good. You guys absolutely killed it, I even think that this is both of your best work including all of your solo videos too. And no, I'm not saying these because of the song, you can trust me in this one. Noel Gallagher Fan Club: Honestly this video was even better than what I was expecting. The first thing that really caught my attention and got me interested was Mask Off, it's such a legendary song and it worked pretty well with the first part. Editing overall was pretty good, not the biggest fan of the B&W CC but it is what it is. Overall this was a pretty dope video, awesome work guys. He clearly said it for the song.
|
|
|
Post by theptsan on Aug 29, 2021 16:09:17 GMT
I love how unique the song choices are by NOEL's Gallagher's Club i love the little audio quotes give a bit more unf to the narration of the story in the MV himself and how the little cards would pop up as the way to criticize Roman in his Babyface phase. And I love how the transitions where crisp and everything was well done. About Golden Broskis the MV was well Produced but in some parts I think could be slightly better. The dolls part felt a bit as Random filler, not saying it was bad. Beacuse the MV was well done but i think it could be a little more synced and some clips could be slightly better. But overall it's a pretty good job for both MVs
|
|
leomercyeditorking
New Member
Rewind Champion
[TI7]Why would I update my status? I am still busy being mafia
Posts: 48
|
Post by leomercyeditorking on Aug 29, 2021 21:00:38 GMT
Golden Broskis: MIW š I don't know what to say to be honest this vid is so perfect, the syncing, the pacing, CC everything is perfect. The song really fits Bray's career. I hope you will collab again if the standars are these. Double KUDOS!
Noel Gallagher Fan Club: I liked the idea of the video and the idea of the intro, but I think you should have put more differences between his two sides like a change of CC, but it's still a good vid, compliments to both guys!
|
|
|
Post by bluevinsmoke on Aug 29, 2021 21:16:44 GMT
Golden Broskis: your works together are always awesome. Your styles are really similar yet everyone have his own touch and way to present things. You reminded how much potential Bray had with his old character and made him look terrifying like he actually shouldāve been.
Noel Gallagher's Fan Club: Iāll be honest and say that I donāt like Roman at all (even after the heel turn), BUT the you showed how he dealt with the hate and the criticism and stop to be the nice guy was really well done (especially the opening which was great). A really good video for a really controversial wrestler.
|
|