|
|
Post by stylopz on Aug 14, 2021 23:01:39 GMT
Remember to vote and feedback both videos (make sure to give substantial feedback). Failure to do so will cause one point to be deducted. Due date is 29th August.
Editor King (c):
STS:
|
|
|
|
Post by Storm on Aug 22, 2021 14:30:59 GMT
Editor King: Editing MCR??? HAHAHHAHHAHAHAHHAHAHHHAHAHHAHHAHAHHHAHAHAHHAHHAHHHAHAHHAHHAHAHHA! As usual your nail your promo editing, that's just a standard at this point. Man that beginning of the match with mixes of all their lock ups was fucking insane, your callbacks are just on another level at this point! Flow of this video was a standout part, like I said you are a master of callbacks but here because of the pace of the song you had to go really fast with everything. Not only you managed to sync everything but you also managed to throw in little callbacks or details of their previous matches without hurting the flow or pacing of the video, it was all going so smoothly and was really easy to follow. There is one detail about this that I think makes this edit stand out compared to others is that when song was slower you would focus on the match, but when it picked up you would use callbacks and honestly I found that absolutely brilliant! It just added to that intensity and added to the feeling of a personal feud that was unique compared to your other matches that were about championships where you would do callbacks to their previous bouts, just brilliant thinking and excellent execution! Loved your idea to use them knocking each other with a clothesline as a moment of reflection to their past and what Ciampa threw away, making him disappear from all the photos and waving to Gargano before he disappears was so powerful! Rain and desaturated look only added to it, the only thing that I wasn't a big fan of was a transition, it was great transition just I wished it resulted straight to the photo or something different than it just just being in the same clip with the same look. Finish was just exceptional, you used that trash and confusing finish and gave it depth with all callbacks to why those moments happened and using memories as finishing clips was a perfect way to finish this intensity filled video. Just a masterpiece and with this you proved that you have every right to be a Rewind champion, if Cheeze had competed I don't see any way how he could have beaten this. Bravo!
STS: First of all thank you so much for showing up in the such a short notice! You are a star! I loved your choice of the match for the video, it was a really damn fun match so I am glad you highlighted it! Love how you used cold color like blue for the kinda sad beginning riff and that transition to color was so damn good! You matched the pace of the edit exceptionally well, from fast paced and hard cuts when song is faster to calmer cuts with crossfades when song slows down. That flashback to Tiger Mask when Tiger Queen was doing his move was such a fantastic little touch, absolutely loved that! Your editing of this match was super intense and you weren't fucking around here, it was such a hard hitting and fast highlight. I like your use of film effect, it weirdly adds that intensity to the video and it compliments your pacing here pretty well! This was just a short and super fun highlight to watch, intense from the start and no flashy bullshit. I think it's my favorite highlight from you and I had a really fun time watching it, I definitely will watch it more. Terrific job!
|
|
Sami
New Member
[TI11]
Posts: 34
|
Post by Sami on Aug 26, 2021 10:55:13 GMT
Editor King : What an absolute amazing video man, I didn't know you I just watched your video and it's when I finished it coming back on this page that I saw that you are the champion and I totally understand why. Your edit is so good. The story of the friendship/rivality was beautifully told starting with all the nice moments they shared together then the moment Ciampa turned on Gargano and then all of their matches, with all the moves being shown twice from different matches I just loved it. It was awesome. The moments where Ciampa on the pics disappears tells so much and is so amazingly done that was dope ! And all the video showed so much intensity it was super. For the negative points, I mean the one that I didn't like even if it wasn't much, was the voices over the music I felt like the music was a bit too loud and we couldn't hear what they were saying and I also felt like there was bit too much of that in the video maybe a bit less could have been better, also the video being a bit too long I think it could have been reduced but I understand that there is so much to tell that it's very complicated and you did it so amazingly that it doesn't even matter and I didn't see the time pass and last one would be the turn of Ciampa on Gargano, I feel like something could have been add with the effect, it would have make it even more epic. But anyways that was a beautiful work and I hope not to face you one day cause I know I wouldn't stand a chance
STS : I loved your edit, it was great and especially choosing this kind of match which is a big risk taken so you got all my respect. I love people showcasing matches that aren't very known. I really liked your style, I recognized mine in it with the different filters and effects used along with the progression of the match so I was pretty surprised but in a positive way. The only negative points I would make would be the quality of the match unfortunately. As I said it was a big risk to take these kind of matches as the production of small promotions/indy promotions are far from being great unfortunately so it's a bit too bad and the end that I think could have been removed, I mean I think that the video could have ended after the pinfall. Otherwise as I said I enjoyed very much and this is a style that I like to watch and try to do, very good work !
|
|
|
|
Post by stylopz on Aug 28, 2021 9:28:38 GMT
Editor King: Damn man, I think this is at the moment your best video, really stellar stuff! The promo usage was good, really good actually giving a damn good build up for what was going to happen. The editing was great and especially I loved the insane lockup flashbacks, those looked so quick and smooth that I was just mesmerized by that. Use of flashbacks was top notch and the editing was damn great. The part after both collided and you made each disappear in the rain overlay was pretty damn emotional and honestly you just put that thought process really well. Your CC was so clean here, really amazing look. IMO this was your best highlight and probably my favorite Gargano vs Ciampa highlight ever.
STS: This was a damn fun video. I wasn't too much of a fan of the blue CC you used it made footage a bit harder to see. Probably my only complaint for the video, as I thought this was a fantastic video, your pacing here was tremendous and I loved how you edited the match. The influences in Tiger Queen are well seen in TM and Dynamite Kid and you showcased it here well with the flashbacks. Loved the film overlays towards the end, they looked fantastic. I really have nothing much to say, it was short and sweet, but with some fantastic editing. Incredible stuff!
|
|
p1
Junior Member
[TI8]
Posts: 80
|
Post by p1 on Aug 29, 2021 12:09:30 GMT
Editor King: Dude, you are more than a king at this point. Everybody knows how big of a mark I am for Ciampa vs Gargano from 2018, and I am an even bigger mark for flashback clips in highlights like this. This video had a fair amount of it and you used it really well, especially those lockup ones, those were fire. I don't think I have to talk about your editing of pre-match promo packages anymore, those are always good and you don't edit it just to edit it, you make it build up a match that's coming after it. I also don't have to talk about your basics, they are really strong and you are adding more complex things to it now and it works a whole lot. The element with rain overlay was super well done and made me feel the emotion of the match even more. Superb work.
STS: This came out of the gate fast, hit hard and went home pretty quickly. I suppose that was how the match itself was done as well, and as much as I love matches like that, I love highlights like this even more. Nothing out of the ordinary, but just tight and super intense, while matching the song with different CCs and overlays, it makes for a really fun watch and a video that flies by pretty quickly. I also love how you tried to showcase a little bit more of Tiger Queen's character and the influence legends like Tiger Mask have on her with those flashbacks. Great work, enjoyed it a lot.
|
|
|
|
Post by Arguden on Aug 29, 2021 16:09:34 GMT
Editor King: I ain't feedbacking a MCR music video. No seriously this video made me MCR Super Emos No.1 Fan, I can't thank you enough for that. Your videos feel even more professional compared to last year, you're improving so fast and it's really nice watching your improvement. Video was really good, possibly your best one so far. Also I absolutely loved what you did with the photos, really fucking creative but I'm sorry, I will forever bully you for 03:16.
Sts: You bring some fresh stuff to the highlights division with every upload. Just like most of your videos I loved the aesthetic of this video, I dig 24fps videos, I don't know if it was on purpose but still it looks really nice. Your flashbacks were on Editor King level, which means it is really impressive. Really good stuff man, hope to see more highlights from you.
|
|
|
|
Post by theptsan on Aug 29, 2021 18:07:00 GMT
This Was Dope.
Editor king:if i didn't knew that was a hightlights video i would think that was just a straight up wwe videopackage,very nice job in deed
Sts:amazing work ike always i love that cheeky tiger mask clip when tiger queen was doing the spot
both of you did a an amzing job
|
|
|
|
Post by bluevinsmoke on Aug 29, 2021 21:42:11 GMT
Editor King: man you reminded me why back then I loved their rivalry so much.
You showed how much their story was personal, because they really hated each other of Ciampa’s betrayal.
Really professional editing, much better than even WWE’s promo packages.
STS: I’m really glad that you made an highlights for this match, it was a really cool debut for the mysterious Tiger Queen.
It was very fun edit for a very fun match with your cool editing style which I like.
|
|
