|
Post by dead sarcastic on Jul 14, 2019 21:55:16 GMT
Remember to vote and feedback both videos (make sure to give substantial feedback). Failure to do so will cause one point to be deducted. Also, make sure to rate both videos in the SSJ and Stylopz Ratings Club thread
SSJ -
Stylopz -
|
|
pk
MEP GEN NEXT
Posts: 21
|
Post by pk on Aug 6, 2019 1:13:22 GMT
Ospreay vids have also become something of a trend. Every Round here at Fight Club I see at least one Will MV. Both of this videos share a lot of similarities, maybe not in the music but the structure is the same with just highlighting his matches. I'm have a problem with those type of MVS in which you just put a series of his matches. And when they have the duration that both of this videos have it gets to a point in which you are just watching Will Ospreay highlights, 7 minutes vids and 9 minutes vids when there's no story is a Nope for me. Sorry if I'm being harsh both of this are good videos and you are good editors but maybe add something to spyce up the video instead of just putting matches. The one from SSJ had really cool effects tho. The aesthetique was great in that one.
|
|
[pain]
Junior Member
Posts: 64
|
Post by [pain] on Aug 6, 2019 20:44:22 GMT
Two videos of Ospreay omg, I will take the edition that I liked the most. My vote is for Stylopz
|
|
|
Post by ssjhighlights on Aug 13, 2019 14:22:10 GMT
*Sips Tea*
|
|
p1
Junior Member
[TI8]
Posts: 80
|
Post by p1 on Aug 22, 2019 20:48:26 GMT
I will agree with PK that these 2 videos share a lot of similarities, especially structure wise. But I have no problem with that, you both told the story well in my opinion and I like to watch this type of videos from time to time.
SSJ: As I said, the story was very well told in this video. Song choices were top notch. You know how much I love Envoi so I don't have to tell anything else. Nightmare part was my favorite because it fits Scurll/Ospreay rivalry perfectly. We Are is a classic song and no matter how many times it gets used I'm gonna love it. Shame you didn't do this one in Vegas tho, I think you would've edited it better even though it was still really enjoyable. Keep it up my broken Sack Sabre Jr!
Stylopz: You also had great song choices, especially Aerials In The Sky. This was my first time listening to it and I can tell it's a damn good song. It was edited well and went really smoothly, although it had some twixtor slowmotions at some weird places, but those are minor complaints. I also think you should've ended the video with some clip with just Ospreay instead of him and Lee. Effects were mostly really good, especially the masking on Shooting Star Press. To be honest, that effect was the deciding factor in this match. One of your best works in my opinion.
Vote: I wish I could give a vote to both but I have to choose one, so I give my vote to Stylopz.
|
|
|
Post by dead sarcastic on Aug 24, 2019 0:25:38 GMT
Stylopz: For someone who is still somewhat a beginner, this is incredible! Even tho editing Ospreay at this point is becoming very very repetitive (kind of like when would edit CM Punk a lot) it's still a highly enjoyable video. Like I've told you before your editing is so out there, and it's great to see a new editor not be afraid to follow others or try to mimic others. Which is something most beginners do. So I applause you for doing the opposite of that. There are some problems that I had with this video. First problem was the length - I feel like 7 minutes is a bit too long for a video that's only recapping the first 6 months of Ospreay's 2019 wrestling matches. I think you could have done this in at least 4-5 minutes. Another problem that I saw was the masking. As much as love how unique the way you used it was, I do think you should try to perfect your masking. I do appreciate you doing it, because takes a long time to do and it's hard work. I loved the transition from the first song to the next one. And I kind of do understand as to why this was 7 minutes, maybe you just wanted to have fun with the effects. Which they were pretty good looking if I'm gonna be honest. Love those scratches, and blur at the edges of the video. I also like how one part shows him wrestling mainly outside of NJPW, and the second half shows his time mainly in NJPW, trying to climb to the top of the Junior division once again! Incredible video, and please keep participating in the group. I'm sure you'll be one of the best in a year from now.
|
|